Warranties in marine insurance policies can take varying forms, from a common survey warranty to a unique provision inserted at the whim of a particular underwriter. Depending on the type of provision and the law applicable to the interpretation of the clause, the breach of a warranty may void or suspend a policy altogether. Alternatively, in certain jurisdictions or in certain cases, the breach may void the policy only if the breach is causally related to the loss or the breach increases the risk. In other situations, the provision may be unenforceable under state statute or under state law rules of contractual interpretation. This Article provides an overview of the treatment of a breach of warranty by various courts, beginning with an overview of various courts’ treatment of particular clauses and concluding with a discussion of a recent case example regarding a breach of an express seaworthiness warranty in a protection and indemnity policy.
Responses are scholarly reactions to Articles appearing in the Tulane Law Review. The Review will only accept submissions of this type for Articles appearing within the last three volumes of the Review(or with an abstract appearing on this Web site). See information and guidelines.
- William C. Baldwin. Attorney, Jones, Walker, L.L.P., New Orleans, Member of the Louisiana Bar; J.D., Tulane University School of Law; B.S., McIntire School of Commerce, University of Virginia.
C. Barrett Rice. Partner, Admiralty & Maritime Practice Group, Jones, Walker, L.L.P., New Orleans; Member of the Louisiana Bar; J.D., Tulane University School of Law; B.A., Northwestern University.
- 87 Tul. L. Rev. 1049 (2013)